The pessimistic worldview reached a new stage this week as the Economist declared that “the liberal international order is falling apart.” SIGnal readers will already be familiar with this idea, but for the Economist to adopt it might reasonably be taken as a sign of the Apocalypse. Meanwhile, the distinguished demographer Nicholas Eberstadt showed at length in Foreign Affairs what a profound demographic crisis East Asia is facing — another SIGnal theme, underlined this week at a desperate press conference given by South Korea’s President Yoon Suk Yeol in which he announced the formation of a Ministry of Low Birth Rate Counter-planning. It was a bad week for optimists, but perhaps the right time to think about a Dystopia Fund.
Macro short-selling is usually done on a national basis, by betting on (or against) currencies. A Dystopia Fund would look to sectors and sub-sectors that would be likely to benefit from long-term negative trends. Humans, even investors, tend to be optimistic, but reality is not. This creates a sort of information disparity that can be exploited.
Last week’s post looked at artificial intelligence in this context. AI, potentially, provides a way for problems of demographic decline to be compensated for by increased productivity within a given national market. The national is important: states large and small have registered that while technology-enabled globalization did indeed bring many tens of millions of people up from poverty, it was driven not by charity but by the extraordinary profits and monopolies that accrued to the companies, overwhelmingly Western, that produced the technology. Now that incomes have grown and capital has accumulated in countries from Saudi Arabia to Singapore, states want to harness technology to grow their own economies and keep wealth in domestic markets. AI promises to do that in that it can increase productivity despite declining populations and, perhaps, poor local education systems.
Other Dystopia Fund targets could be in travel and entertainment for the very old, a growing demographic. Various forms of nostalgia would be investable. Great sums of money in recent decades have gone into market research on people in prime consumer age ranges. Not so much money has gone into understanding elderly consumers. The market-research firm that embraces demographic decline would be worth backing.
An aging population puts transport innovations like self-driving cars into a different light. Most transport systems are only friendly to people who can walk and drive. Companies designing systems for the elderly will find their consumer market steadily increasing. By the same token, tele-medicine, home drug delivery, home medical-testing, and other services for the home-bound will also find growing markets. Working from home, despite its many disadvantages, will provide a way to keep older people active in the job market as the (traditional) working-age population shrinks.
Parag Khanna has led the way in identifying regions that will do relatively well out of climate change — a perfect Dystopia Fund sector. Khanna sees climate-driven emigration as something to be optimized for rather than bemoaned, for the simple reason that it is inevitable. Technologies that can extend the habitability of currently populated areas would be another way to approach the challenges of real estate in a changing climate.
One frequently cited reason to regret the demise of the liberal international order is that challenges like demographic shrinkage and climate change are on such a scale that they would benefit from international coordination. While that is certainly true, liberal internationalism’s vitality has been rooted in optimism, whereas what might be needed now is investment strategies based on a pessimism that accepts the profundity of climate and demographic change and their effects on the status quo.
Click to subscribe to SIGnal and receive notifications when new posts are available.